Answered: Our readers create a Hallmark holiday movie fit for Raleigh

We asked, and you delivered. Read how two Hallmark holiday movie characters would fall in love in the City of Oaks and who our readers cast.

Christmas decor at The Angus Barn

Is The Angus Barn the perfect setting for a Hallmark movie? Our readers share their thoughts.

Photo by RALtoday

Table of Contents

Raleigh has not yet been home to a Hallmark holiday movie set, so we decided to do the hard work for the TV channel. We asked our readers to cast + write a Raleigh-themed holiday movie — here are your responses.

Where does the meet cute happen?

Miracle at The Haymaker. He orders a ‘Yippie Ki Yay Mother F------!’ and she comments that ‘Die Hard’ isn’t a Christmas movie. Chaos ensues!” - Elizabeth C.

Saving Grace. They are passionate about rescuing animals!” - June G.

“They’ve run into each other before, she was a vendor at the NC State Fair, and he was nothing but rude. Now when he took his niece to the NC Asheboro Zoo, they quite literally run into each other again.” - Jordan B.

“On the greenway network.” - Nanette N.

Two festive holiday drinks.

Try this: The Christmapolitan served in a classic coup glass at The Haymaker.

Photo by RALtoday

How do they bond?

“Shared love for the most heavily seasoned everything bagel in town at Benchwarmers.” - Sarah B.

“Over love of coffee — chain brand versus local favorite like 321 Coffee.” - Mary S.

“He works at Angus Barn as the sommelier and tries to smooth over her holiday reservation incident with a bottle of wine.” - Vanessa N.

“Tobacco Road college sports rivalries.” - Betsy A., K. H., Casey S., Justice D., and Cyndi W.

What other plot points are there?

“He shows her the magic of a cookout tray, definitely with a giant Cheerwine.” - Riley B.

“British bloke falls for local man during a hockey tailgate.” - George S.

“They would have to help create a float for the Cary holiday parade, when Santa’s float suddenly goes kaput.” - Jordan B.

“Small town protagonist is scared of the big city and that it won’t be welcoming. They turn to find out Raleigh is a small-feeling big city. They learn this by experiencing the art, culture, holiday pop-ups, markets, and charm of Raleigh.” - Kevin B.

Where will the final scene take place?

“In City Plaza watching the Acorn Drop.” - Tammy H., Ann D., Justice D., Cyndi W. and Nanette N.

“A performance by the NC Symphony.” - Riley B.

“Ashley Christensen’s New Year’s Eve dinner at Poole’s Diner.” - Sarah B.

“He chases after her on the Raleigh Trolley light tour on Christmas Eve.” - Jordan B.

Which actors should play the lead characters?

Ariana DeBose and Scotty McCreery.” - June G.

“Tyler Barnhardt and Hunter Schafer.” - Riley B.

“Priyanka Chopra Jonas and Manish Dayal.” - Kathryn S.

“Micheal C. Hall and Lacey Chabert.” - Jordan B.

“Susie Pratt and Ira David Wood IV.” - Vanessa N.

“Zach Galifianakis should be in it as another character (not the romantic interest).” - Justice D.

More from RALtoday
The annual Great Backyard Bird Count attracts over a million bird lovers nationwide to help record the bird population — here’s how you can get involved in Raleigh.
Valentine’s Day is just around the corner. Don’t be caught empty-handed — use our guide to classic gifts fit for your sweetheart right here in Raleigh.
Dig into Raleigh’s must-try pizza shops including NC State hangouts, high-end Detroit-style pizza, and bagel shops moonlighting as pizzerias. Whatever style you prefer, there’s pizza in Raleigh for you.
Move aside pickleball, there’s a new racket sport in town.
Get your hats and mittens — it’s finally snow season in Raleigh. While the 919 isn’t known for its wintery weather, we’re holding out hope for some history-making snowfall soon.
The Super Bowl is right around the corner, and we’ve got five local sports bars to catch the big game at with everything from raffle prizes to a soup showdown.
Plan your next snowy adventure with these 10 resorts to ski, snowboard, and tube within five hours of Oak City.
The Olympics are nearly here, and there are plenty of Olympians with local ties, from NHL players to college students.
Raleighites can get around town and the greater area through GoRaleigh and GoTriangle. Learn how to ride the bus in Raleigh for public transportation through Raleigh + the greater Triangle.
Got a hot new fling? Hoping to spice things up with your longtime partner? We’re here to help plan your next date night in the 919.